/theprobe/media/media_files/2026/11/18/whistleblower-law-that-was-never-enforced-2026-11-18-14-17-14.jpg)
The Whistle Blowers Protection Act was passed by Parliament in 2014. Twelve years on, it has still not been brought into force. Illustration: The Probe
The Whistleblower Haryana Suspended for Defending a Sanctuary
In early 2007, a young forest officer in Haryana stopped contractors from felling trees and driving heavy machinery through a wildlife sanctuary to build a canal. Contractors of the state’s irrigation department had felled trees and run heavy machinery through the Saraswati Wildlife Sanctuary, merging about five acres of the state’s largest protected area into the Hansi-Butana canal. A Supreme Court order of February 2000 barred canal digging in sanctuaries without the Court’s permission. Sanjiv Chaturvedi, then the divisional forest officer at Kurukshetra, insisted the order be obeyed.
Also Read: A Whistleblower Nobody Will Judge: The Sanjiv Chaturvedi Question
Within weeks he was transferred on an order that originated in the Chief Minister’s office. On 25 July the Forest Minister proposed his suspension. On 31 July the Chief Minister approved that his explanation be called first. On 2 August the Chief Minister’s aide recorded that the file had been “called from office” and that “on reconsideration” the Chief Minister had approved suspension. No reason for the reversal was written down. The order came the next day.
That file is now before the Supreme Court, in a case Chaturvedi filed in 2012. In 2014, Parliament passed a law to protect whistleblowers. The government never brought it into force. Chaturvedi is now asking the Supreme Court to step in.
The Centre, CBI and CVC Backed the Whistleblower. Haryana Blocked Them
What followed the suspension is recorded in a government enquiry, not in Chaturvedi’s words. In 2010 the Ministry of Environment and Forests set up a two-member committee after he complained to the Cabinet Secretary and the President. It examined around 108 documents and reported in December 2010 that he had been harassed “through all the means available”, listing “frequent transfers, long spells without posting, arbitrary suspension, issuing a fabricated charge-sheet, keeping the charge-sheet pending for long period to stall the promotion, registration of false cases, spoiling the ACR, etc., only for doing his statutory duties”. In about five years he had received twelve posting orders and spent two and a half years without a cadre post. The committee recommended a CBI investigation because, with the Chief Minister’s office, senior ministers and senior bureaucrats involved, no state agency could conduct an impartial inquiry.
The chain of approvals that followed is unusual for its completeness. The Central Vigilance Commission asked in July 2011 that he be given protection. The CBI reported on 1 November 2011 that the matter was fit for its investigation. The CVC agreed on 16 December 2011. On 1 March 2012 the Union government asked Haryana to register a case and hand it to the CBI. The Prime Minister’s Office wrote to the ministry in May 2012 about his harassment. In 2014 the Intelligence Bureau, asked to assess the threat to him, found that “there appears to be truth in the contention of Sanjiv Chaturvedi regarding alleged harassment meted out to him by Haryana Government”. Four times between 2008 and 2014 the President of India set aside orders Haryana had passed against him.
None of it produced an investigation. Under Section 6 of the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, the CBI cannot investigate in a state without that state’s consent. Haryana refused. One refusal was enough to stop a central enquiry, the CVC, the CBI and the Union government together.
That is the gap the Whistle Blowers Protection Act was written to close. Section 11 of the Act obliges the Central Government to “ensure that no person or a public servant who has made a disclosure under this Act is victimised by initiation of any proceedings or otherwise”. In 2007, and every year since, no law has placed that duty on anyone, because the Act has never come into force; a 2004 government resolution gives limited cover to central employees but does not reach the states.
Also Read: Uttarakhand Eco Tourism Scam: Officer Who Exposed Corruption Transferred
The Whistleblower’s Supreme Court Petition Has Waited Fourteen Years
With the state’s refusal standing, only a constitutional court could send in the CBI, and Sanjiv Chaturvedi went to the Supreme Court. Chaturvedi filed a petition in the Supreme Court in November 2012, asking it to direct the CBI to take over the cases the Centre had wanted it to investigate. Two of the judges who heard it, Ranjan Gogoi in 2013 and U.U. Lalit in 2016, recused without giving reasons. Both went on to become Chief Justice of India. The petition is now fourteen years old and has not been decided.
The reprisals did not pause for the Court. In March 2014, after the Supreme Court had said the case “may be disposed of at the stage of admission”, Haryana filed its own petition in the Punjab and Haryana High Court to have the enquiry report declared illegal. In May 2016 the state’s own Additional Advocate General advised withdrawing it, because the Supreme Court was seized of the matter. The advice was overridden. In August 2019 the High Court threw the petition out as not maintainable, holding that the dispute was “essentially between the Government of India and State Government” and that the Supreme Court was “already seized of similar controversy”.
In between, the file disappeared. In March 2018 Chaturvedi asked under the Right to Information Act for the file noting on how the Additional Advocate General’s advice had been overruled. The file came back to the forest branch from the Chief Minister’s office without its original noting portion. The state’s Forest Secretary directed on 25 April 2018 that a police case be registered if the papers were not found. No FIR was ever registered. The superintendent who was custodian of the file lodged a lost-article report instead.
The man who reported the file missing was Rajinder Singh Chhillar, the superintendent in the forest branch who had custody of it. No police case was ever registered. On 21 May 2018 Chhillar lodged a lost-article report. Three weeks later, on 13 June, he was transferred out of the forest branch. In July he was served a major-penalty charge memorandum. According to Chaturvedi’s filing, its only charge was that Chhillar had lodged the lost-article report. In a written representation that December, Chhillar stated that on the day of his transfer, in the office of the Additional Chief Secretary for forests and in front of other officers, he had received telephone calls, one after another, from two of the state’s most senior officials, who threatened “to destroy me and my family”. He said he was moved out within ten minutes of leaving that room. According to Chaturvedi’s filing, he retired in January 2019 with about Rs 28 lakh in retirement dues withheld, and died on 23 October 2020, aged about 59, with the charge still pending and the money unpaid. His case is part of what Chaturvedi now asks the Supreme Court to have the CBI investigate.
The Intelligence Bureau report that found “truth” in Chaturvedi’s complaint of harassment has still not been given to him. The Central Information Commission ordered its release in April 2016, finding it “factually proved that appellant was put to extreme hardship by the corrupt political rulers and corrupt public servants in retaliation of his unstinted implementation of rule of law”. The Delhi High Court upheld that in August 2017. The IB’s appeal has been pending for nine years, and two directions to produce the report, in 2023 and 2024, have not been complied with.
Also Read: Uttarakhand Eco Tourism Scam: Report Alleges Loot, State Looks Away
From One Officer’s Case to Protection for Every Whistleblower
The Whistle Blowers Protection Act was passed by the Lok Sabha in December 2011 and the Rajya Sabha in February 2014, received the President’s assent on 9 May 2014 and was published in the Gazette three days later. Section 1(3) left its commencement to a government notification. That notification has never been issued.
The government’s reason has not changed in twelve years: the Act needs amendments first, to guard against disclosures affecting “sovereignty and integrity of India, security of the State” and similar interests. An amendment bill passed the Lok Sabha on 13 May 2015, went to the Rajya Sabha, and lapsed when the 16th Lok Sabha was dissolved in 2019. It has not been reintroduced. The government confirmed the position to Parliament on 4 December 2019, on 4 December 2024 and again on 11 December 2025. India ratified the United Nations Convention against Corruption in May 2011; the convention asks member countries to consider protecting people who report corruption in good faith.
On 27 October 2026 Chaturvedi filed an additional affidavit in his fourteen-year-old petition asking the Court to widen it. His written submissions ask for three things: a CBI investigation, monitored by the Court, into the harassment from 2007 onwards, including the vanished file and the death of Chhillar; exemplary compensation; and a direction to the Union to decide “within a time fixed by this Court” whether to bring the Act into force, with the Court laying down “an interim framework/guidelines for whistleblower protection, in Central Govt. as well as under State Govt” until it does.
The precedent he relies on is the Court’s own. In 2017, hearing a petition by the non-profit Common Cause, the Supreme Court refused to let the government keep the Lokpal Act on hold while it waited to amend it. The Act, the Court said, “as it stands today is an eminently workable piece of legislation and there is no justification to keep the enforcement of the Act under suspension till the amendments”. The whistleblower Act has been held in suspension on the same ground, pending amendments, for twelve years.
The submissions also point to what the Court did when there was no law at all: the Vishaka guidelines on sexual harassment at work in 1997, the police reform directions in Prakash Singh in 2006, the custodial safeguards in D.K. Basu. “Where there is inaction even by the executive, for whatever reason, the judiciary must step in,” the Court said in Vineet Narain in 1997. The whistleblower petition asks it to say so again.
The petitioner is, by any measure, the strongest test case the country could offer. The Union Health Ministry rated his integrity “absolute” after his two years as Chief Vigilance Officer at AIIMS. The Ramon Magsaysay Award followed in 2015. His own cadre was changed to Uttarakhand that year on grounds of extreme hardship, with Haryana’s consent. A whistleblower with that record has had to go to the President four times, to the tribunal, the information commissions, three High Courts and the Supreme Court merely to protect himself against reprisals. The superintendent who reported a missing file had no forum at all, and, according to Chaturvedi’s filing, died with his retirement dues still withheld.
On 28 October the Court recorded that the additional affidavit was not yet on record, directed the registry to verify it, and listed the matter for 10 December 2026 at 2 pm.
/theprobe/media/agency_attachments/gYIwb1QtL4tWjJtmo7Fx.png)
Follow Us