Rahul Gandhi Blames a 2008 Money Flood for Congress Fall

Rahul Gandhi says a 2008 money flood and vanishing voters undid the Congress. Can the grand old party fight back before Uttar Pradesh votes in 2027?

author-image
Sanjay Kapoor
New Update
Rahul Gandhi on BJP and Election Commission of India

Rahul Gandhi says money and missing voters have reshaped India’s elections since 2014. (Illustration: The Probe)

Listen to this article
0.75x1x1.5x
00:00/ 00:00

At the Hyderabad International Convention Centre on November 14, Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi made a significant speech at the Bharat Summit, where he traced the decimation of the Congress party in 2014 to the collapse of the world economy and the actions governments took to sort out that crisis.

Also Read:  Why the Modi Trump Playbook Won’t Survive a Democratic House

“What worked for us and for many other people and countries on the planet, the economic model that worked for us, has failed.... That model collapsed in 2008,” he said. “And when it collapsed, a massive amount of money was printed. Huge liquidity was created. And that liquidity devastated our political system.”

That flood of money, in his telling, went on to transform the electoral landscape in 2014.He alleged that the BJP’s assets had grown elevenfold over a decade and declared that India was “no longer a democracy”. The BJP rejected the charges and demanded an apology.

The Congress lost the 2014 election on the issue of corruption and what was colourfully called policy paralysis, when the government helmed by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, with a cabinet loaded with the likes of AK Antony, kept its claws buried within its paws and avoided taking decisions. The BJP, projected as the counterpoint to the Manmohan Singh government, presented itself as squeaky clean and decisive, an image its propaganda cell spun among its noisy followers. Much of the anger against the Congress was of its own making.

Advertisment

How 2014 Broke the Congress

Now the Congress leader says the BJP may have manipulated elections in its favour, and that democracy itself was destroyed in 2014. What was truly dramatic was the fall of the Congress from 206 seats to 44. This was extraordinary in many ways. Its vote share fell by more than nine percentage points, from 28.55 per cent to below 20 per cent, the first time it had ever dropped under that mark.

The Congress leadership had its shoulders drooping even before the results came, but the referee also had questions to answer. In April 2014, the Election Commission  barred Amit Shah, then running the BJP’s campaign in Uttar Pradesh, from holding rallies over his “revenge” remarks, only to lift the ban within a week after he gave an undertaking. Needless to say, this was forgotten as too small a matter when the national mood was so high strung. The country was still reeling from the Nirbhaya gang rape of December 2012, which had drawn civil society groups and thousands of young people onto the streets of Delhi in protests that badly bruised the government.

There are some uncomfortable questions here, and they involve the party’s view of its own leadership. The big question concerns the late former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. Did the Congress leader consider him inadequate, someone who frittered away the future to a party that changed the way the country conducted itself, making it less secular and more majoritarian? More investigation into the business of elections will reveal this and more.

Also Read:  General Elections 2024: Explosive Footage Reveals Troubling Reality

Rahul Gandhi and the Machinery of the State

In 2019, the Congress again felt short changed. In November 2018, months before the polls, Union minister Piyush Goyal said a survey he had commissioned showed the BJP winning between 297 and 303 seats. The party won 303. Goyal is no pollster or astrologer, and the precision of his numbers still raises eyebrows. After that defeat, Rahul Gandhi resigned as Congress president, writing that the party had fought “the entire machinery of the Indian state”.

Ever since he shook off the stupor of losing elections, the Congress leader has become more trenchant in his criticism of how elections are conducted in the country. He has stopped short of claiming that electronic voting machines (EVMs) were tampered with, though in June 2024 he called them a “black box” that nobody is allowed to scrutinise and asked the Election Commission of India to make them fully transparent or abolish them. His main focus, instead, has been on how names are added to and removed from electoral rolls.

In August 2025, Rahul Gandhi alleged that over a lakh fake voters had been added in Bengaluru’s Mahadevapura Assembly segment, and in September that names were being deleted through centralised software, accusing Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar of protecting those responsible. The ECI called his September claims “incorrect and baseless”. Asked whether the party would go to court, he sidestepped the question. His sample was small, but the controversy over the rolls has since grown far larger than his presentations.

Thirteen Crore Names and a Divided Commission

The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls has since deleted names wholesale. By several counts, about 13 crore names, close to the population of Mexico, have been struck off the rolls since the exercise began in Bihar in June 2025. The opposition alleges that minorities, Dalits and other disadvantaged voters have been hit hardest; the BJP says some 2.8 crore of those removed were dead voters. In Hyderabad, Rahul Gandhi went further, alleging that 140 million people who voted were later declared non-existent or invalid.

In West Bengal, about 91 lakh names, nearly 12 per cent of the electorate, were deleted before the Assembly election in which the BJP won 207 seats and ended Mamata Banerjee’s 15-year rule. Data analyses suggest the deletions may have played a significant part in the Trinamool Congress’s defeat, though that remains contested. In Uttar Pradesh, the draft rolls alone excluded 2.89 crore voters.

The issue turned explosive in Delhi, when voters found that notices over “discrepancies” had gone out even to a sitting Election Commissioner, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri and former Vice-President Jagdeep Dhankhar. The Delhi poll office insisted that a notice did not mean deletion. But the episode showed how arbitrary a process driven by system-generated notices and the judgement of the ECI’s booth level officers (BLOs) could look.

Then, on September 23, 2026, The Indian Express revealed that two of the three members of the Commission, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, had formally objected at least 14 times in 10 months to decisions on the SIR, voter registration and electoral roll data. The law expects the Commission to act unanimously where possible and by majority where it cannot. If two of the three objected 14 times, the big question is who gave Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar the strength to stand up to his colleagues.

The ECI maintains that its decisions were unanimous. These are questions with no easy answers. Critics also point to the Supreme Court, which allowed the exercise to continue in its early stages even as protests followed every new list of deletions. It has since agreed to hear a petition arguing that the SIR is void because the CEC acted without the full Commission. 

Also Read:  ECI Software Can't Recognise Twins, Leaving Delhi Families in Limbo

Was 2024 Stolen, as Rahul Gandhi Suggests?

Many in the opposition believe the 2024 election was stolen from the Congress, a view the Leader of the Opposition now voices openly. In Varanasi, Prime Minister Narendra Modi trailed Ajay Rai of the Congress by about 6,000 votes after the first round of counting, before winning by 1,52,513 votes, his lowest margin from the seat. Rahul Gandhi later claimed that had his sister Priyanka Gandhi Vadra contested, the Prime Minister would have lost by two to three lakh votes.

More recently, The Reporters’ Collective, examining returning officers’ reports that the ECI does not make public, found that the Commission kept no count of voting after 5 pm, an hour before polling closed, in 200 Assembly and Lok Sabha constituencies across Maharashtra, Haryana and Jammu and Kashmir. An earlier report by the same group found that votes polled and votes counted did not match in 32 seats, and that officials had recorded zero voters in 19 more; the ECI called the claims misleading. If there is merit in these findings, was the 2024 election stolen? The evidence so far raises serious questions. It does not yet answer them.

The Congress will get another opportunity when Uttar Pradesh votes in 2027. Can the grand old party win now that it is armed with the knowledge of how elections are won in India? Knowing how the game is played is not the same as winning it. That will need an organisation the Congress has struggled to build in the state, and proof from Rahul Gandhi that can stand up in a court, not just at a press conference.

Democracy Uttar Pradesh Rahul Gandhi BJP Election commission of India Congress dow-jones Elections Gyanesh Kumar